Nice Guys:
Darrell [Road Rules 11: Campus Crawl]
Jamie [Real World 14: San Diego]
Landon [Real World 15: Philadelphia]
Mike [Real World 10: Back To New York]

Mission 01: Bad Asses (Nominees: Dan vs. Mike)
Mission 02: Bad Asses (Nominees: Dan vs. Jon)
Eliminated: Jon [Real World 02: Los Angeles]
Mission 03: Bad Asses (Nominees: Tina vs. Robin)
Mission 04: Good Guys (Nominees: Tina vs. Robin)
Eliminated: Robin [Real World 14: San Diego]
Left: Beth [Real World 02: Los Angeles]
Mission 05: Good Guys (Nominees: Karamo vs. Mike)
Mission 06: Bad Asses (Nominees: Karamo vs. Landon)
Eliminated: Karamo [Real World 15: Philadelphia]
Mission 07: Bad Asses (Nominees: Veronica vs. Jodi)
Mission 08: Good Guys (Nominees: Veronica vs. Jodi)
Eliminated: Jodi [Road Rules 13; X-Treme] 
Mission 09: Good Guys (Nominees: Abram vs. Mike)
Mission 10: Bad Asses (Nominees: Abram vs. Brad)
Eliminated: Brad [Real World 14: San Diego]
Mission 11: Good Guys (Nominees: Tonya vs. Julie)
Mission 12: Bad Asses (Nominees: Tonya vs. Julie)
Eliminated: Julie [Real World 09: New Orleans]
Mission 13: Good Guys (Nominees: Dan vs. Landon)
Mission 14: Good Guys (Nominees: Dan vs. Landon)
Eliminated: Dan [Real World 05: Miami]
Mission 15: Good Guys (Nominees: Tonya vs. Shavonda)
Eliminated: Shavonda [Real World 15: Philadelphia]
Winning Team: Good Guys